(29) Cognitive, affective, and motivational effects of non-essential game elements in a digital, gamified associative learning task
Published in University of Graz, 2026
In gamified learning, multimedia learning principles suggest that non-essential design elements may trigger extraneous processing and thereby impair learning. At the same time, such elements may enhance motivation through generative processing, potentially improving learning outcomes. Because these cognitive processes have antagonistic effects, the overall impact of non-essential game elements remains unclear. To clarify how such elements influence learning in digital associative learning tasks, a series of experiments was conducted as part of this dissertation. In a first online experiment, we showed that non-essential game elements can enhance learners’ motivation, particularly by reducing early disengagement from an online learning task with low external incentives. In a second online experiment, we examined this affective-motivational influence in more detail and found that it can positively affect cognitive learning outcomes, mediated through positive affect and motivation. Comparing both online experiments with a third experiment in the laboratory, we obtained evidence that motivational effects may be more sensitive to boundary conditions than direct cognitive effects on learning. In a fourth and a fifth experiment, using more educationally relevant contexts (i.e., homework and in-class assignments), we again observed moderate motivational benefits accompanied by small negative cognitive effects in adult learners and in students in grades 5-8, respectively. Overall, our findings suggest that non-essential design elements in gamified learning tasks may, but do not reliably, provide motivational benefits, potentially mediated in part through their influence on positive affect. When present, these benefits can indirectly enhance cognitive learning outcomes and partially offset small negative effects due to extraneous processing. Consequently, whether such elements should be implemented depends on instructional goals and on the specific conditions under which they are used, highlighting the need for further research on boundary conditions.
Get a copy of the dissertation here
Recommended citation: Huber, S. E. (2026). Cognitive, affective, and motivational effects of non-essential game elements in a digital, gamified associative learning task [Doctoral dissertation, University of graz].
